Share
Your old VHS tapes hold some of your most precious memories — birthdays, home movies, special moments. It’s tempting to think: “I’ll just send them off to a service and let someone else handle the digitization.” But the truth is, there are real risks when mailing away physical tapes — risks many people have experienced firsthand. In this post, we’ll explore the common dangers of shipping VHS tapes off, walk through actual user stories from Reddit, and make the case for why using the RVT Digitizer at home gives you control, safety, and peace of mind.
Why People Ship Their Tapes Off (and why the idea seems
attractive)
Mail-in services like LegacyBox market themselves as convenient and professional. Customers often choose them because they don’t want to deal with hardware, believe the companies are experts, and hope to save time. Bulk deals and promotions also make them seem like a good bargain. But for many people, the experience doesn’t live up to the promise.
Real Risks of Shipping VHS Tapes: What Redditors Share
Below are common risks mentioned by real Reddit users when they mailed in their tapes to digitization services.
1. Long Delays, “Waiting in Warehouse,” and Poor Communication
Many users said their tapes sat for weeks or months with little to no communication. Updates often jumped from 'in queue' to 'shipped' without explanation. “We sent in 22 VHS tapes … they sat in their Receiving warehouse for 3 weeks … now 8 weeks later, they haven’t even started on our beloved tapes.”
2. Damage, Missing Portions, Blank Files, or 'Cannot Process'
Claims
Physical damage during shipping or handling is a common complaint. Some customers reported broken cases, missing segments, or entire blank videos. “I had sent in 20+ VHS tapes … most came physically damaged as their packing was lacking … the VHS cases are broken and damaged.”
3. Overcharging, Upsells, and Hidden Fees
What begins as a seemingly affordable service often balloons in cost. Customers report surprise charges for expedited handling, storage, or processing. “They tried to price gouge me by offering to ‘expedite’ my order for an extra $89. We already paid $230.”
4. Poor Quality Transfers / Missing Fidelity
Even when tapes are returned, quality can disappoint. Users mention poor fidelity, audio sync issues, or incomplete recordings. “They are notorious for doing bad transfers … Find a local digitization company with good reviews.”
Why These Risks Matter
Irreplaceable family memories are at stake. Once a tape is lost or damaged, it cannot be replaced. Mail-in services take away your control, introduce unnecessary risk, and leave many families with anxiety and regret.
The Better Alternative: Digitizing In-House with RVT
The RVT Digitizer puts you in charge. With it, your tapes never leave your home. You control handling, quality, and timing. The device includes upgraded RCA cables, a reliable power supply, and a USB drive, so you can start digitizing right away. This removes the risks of shipping, ensures higher confidence, and gives you peace of mind knowing your tapes are safe.
Tips to Get the Best Results When Using RVT
• Store tapes carefully (cool, dry, vertical orientation). • Rewind tapes fully before capture. • Use good cables and avoid long runs. • Inspect captured files and rescan if needed. • Back up outputs immediately.
Conclusion & Call to Action
Shipping your VHS tapes to mail-in services sounds convenient, but real customers online have shared heartbreaking stories of damage, delays, blanks, hidden fees, and poor quality. For many, the risk to irreplaceable memories is simply too great. With the RVT Digitizer, you take back the reins. You guard your tapes, control quality, work at your own pace, and avoid the pitfalls of opaque third-party services.
